Can a sole proprietorship receive payment from a foreign counterparty on Wise, Paypal or another payment system?
Reviews of our Clients
It is now common for individual entrepreneurs (sole proprietors, FOPs) in Ukraine engaged in foreign economic activity to receive income through payment systems abroad (Wise, PayPal, Payoneer, and others).
Most sole proprietors who are single tax payers still include this income in their total turnover and pay tax on it at the preferential rate. For a long time, legislation provided little guidance on this approach. However, changes in the legal framework over the past few years call for further analysis.
How much has changed? What are the risks, and how can sole proprietors protect their interests? This article addresses these questions.
Read also: Opening a Personal Account Abroad for a Ukrainian Citizen
How Does the Tax Authority View Sole Proprietors Receiving Payments via Wise, PayPal, or Other Systems?
For a long time, the State Tax Service (STS) offered virtually no response to questions about the taxation of FOP income received through foreign payment systems. The Tax Code of Ukraine (TCU) does not expressly prohibit applying the single tax to this income. In the absence of an STS position, most sole proprietors paid tax on this income at the preferential rate. The situation began to change in 2022.
First, the STS issued a clarification clearly stating that income received by a resident individual from sources outside Ukraine is included in total annual taxable income as foreign income and is subject to personal income tax under the general rules.
Finally, on May 12, 2023, the STS issued another clarification specifically addressing Wise. Its conclusion was that if funds received under foreign economic contracts are credited to an account opened in Wise rather than to a foreign currency account for business purposes at a Ukrainian bank, those funds are excluded from the income of a sole proprietor who is a single tax payer, but are taxed under the rules applicable to individual taxpayers.
The tax authorities' position is therefore clear: income that a sole proprietor receives from business activities into a payment system account and does not transfer to a foreign currency account in Ukraine must be taxed under the general rules (18% personal income tax (PIT) + 1.5% military levy + 22% single social contribution (SSC)).
Given this STS position, let us consider the options for sole proprietors who wish to continue using payment systems.
Read also:Can Ukrainian Sole Proprietors Open Accounts Abroad and Receive Payments for Services?
Option 1: Continue Reporting This Income as FOP Income Subject to the Single Tax. Do Not Transfer the Income to Ukraine.
For now, the STS has limited means of tracking transfers to a sole proprietor's account with a foreign payment system.
Ukraine currently has a register of payment systems that are subject to regulation by Ukrainian government authorities and about which the STS can obtain information. However, most popular payment systems (PayPal, Wise) are absent from this register.
This means that the STS can obtain information about transactions through these payment systems only during a tax audit of a particular sole proprietor. There are few grounds for an unscheduled tax audit of a sole proprietor who pays all taxes and files tax returns on time. Based on statistics, specialists estimate the likelihood of such an audit at no more than 1%. However, the likelihood of an audit increases significantly when a sole proprietor ceases business operations, which should be kept in mind in certain cases.
At the same time, the situation could change dramatically as early as next year. Law No. 2970-IX, adopted on March 20, 2023, provides for the automatic exchange of tax information (CRS) between the STS and foreign tax authorities/financial institutions. Under this law, the first exchange of information about Ukrainian residents' existing accounts abroad will take place after September 30, 2024.
Risks. Until the information exchange deadlines mentioned above take effect, the risk of the STS treating this income as taxable under the general rules can be assessed as below average. This is primarily because the STS cannot verify the source of the funds without auditing the particular sole proprietor, and because legislation still does not adequately address this issue, as discussed below.
Read also: IT Immigration to Georgia for Ukrainian Specialists
Option 2. Continue Reporting This Income as FOP Income Subject to the Single Tax. First Transfer the Funds to Foreign Currency Accounts in Ukraine.
On the one hand, this is consistent with the STS position, since the income ultimately reaches Ukraine. However, the tax authority's latest recommendations and letters suggest that taxable income arises when the funds are transferred, meaning when they are credited to the payment system account. The sole proprietor must therefore pay tax at the first stage of the transaction. Under this option, it would consequently be more advantageous either to receive payments from the client directly into an account in Ukraine or to continue defending the position that this income is subject to the single tax rate.
Risks. There are no risks if the client transfers the funds directly to an account in Ukraine. However, the sole proprietor will clearly incur certain financial losses on such a transaction (bank fees, exchange rate losses, etc.).
A two-stage transaction (first to a payment system, then to an account in Ukraine) may carry a risk that the income will be treated as taxable under the general rules, given the current STS position.
Read also: Tax Residency in Cyprus: Do You Need to Pay Taxes?
Option 3. The STS Obtains Information About FOP Income Received into a Payment System Account.
This is the worst-case scenario, and one you should be prepared for.
As noted above, the STS has already established its position. If this scenario occurs, court proceedings will be the only way to defend your position.
There is currently no case law on this issue. However, a particular interpretation of existing legislation allows you to build a defense based primarily on the principle that laws take precedence over subordinate regulations, as well as sole proprietors' freedom to use their income.
A sole proprietor may use the following arguments in court:
- The TCU does not expressly prohibit applying the single tax to FOP income received into foreign accounts, nor does it require that such income be taxed under the general rules. At the same time, paragraph 291.5 of the TCU clearly specifies the circumstances in which a sole proprietor cannot be a single tax payer. Since the TCU has the status of a law and legally takes precedence over STS clarifications/tax consultations, this can be used in the relevant court dispute.
- The income received through payment systems was credited to a business account, meaning an account that meets the definition of a corporate account used specifically to receive income from business activities.
- Demonstrate to the court that this income was specifically earned through the sole proprietor's business activities and that the transaction is consistent with the very nature and purpose of entrepreneurship. Moreover, the sole proprietor did not conceal the income, but declared it and paid tax on it in Ukraine. Naturally, all invoices and relevant documentation must be provided to support this position.
In such a court dispute, the STS may use another argument in its favor: under currency legislation, a sole proprietor is required to transfer this income to their bank account in Ukraine.
The following counterarguments may be used:
- Legislation does not set a deadline for transferring foreign currency (i.e., foreign income) if the contract concerns services (paragraph 1 of NBU Board Resolution No. 67 of May 14, 2019).
- A sole proprietor has the right to use their income at their own discretion (STS tax consultation No. 100/IPK/99-00-04-03-03-06 of February 21, 2022), including deciding how and when to transfer foreign currency proceeds to Ukraine.
Risks. Given the latest STS clarifications, the risk of court proceedings being initiated over this issue can be assessed as high.
It is difficult to predict a court's decision, primarily because there is no case law. At least the sole proprietor's arguments presented above appear consistent and, most importantly, aligned with the law and the logic of business taxation. STS clarifications, in turn, cannot be regarded as regulatory acts, and this issue remains unresolved in legislation.
Read also: How Can Ukrainian IT Specialists Work Legally Abroad?
If These Payments Are Treated as FOP Income, Could There Be Fiscalization Issues or Fines for Failing to Use a Cash Register (RRO)?
It all depends on exactly how payments between the sole proprietor and the client are processed through the payment system.
First, it should be noted that direct payment from the client's bank account to the sole proprietor's bank account, with IBAN or SWIFT details shown, does not require an RRO.
As for electronic payments:
Under Article 3 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Use of Cash Registers in Trade, Catering, and Services," an RRO is mandatory when electronic payment instruments are used. These include internet acquiring, meaning payments made using bank cards.
It also matters how the payment is identified in the payment system and what payment type appears on the sole proprietor's account statement. For example, a PayPal statement will explicitly identify a card payment as Direct Credit Card Payment.
On the other hand, under Article 9 of the above law, an RRO is not used for service payments made exclusively through:
- remote banking systems;
and/or - money transfer services.
Key conclusions regarding RROs:
- If the client pays for services by bank card and the funds reach the sole proprietor's account, for example, in PayPal, and the payment can be identified as a card payment, an RRO is mandatory;
- If the client pays for services by bank card and the funds reach PayPal, and the payment can be identified as a card payment, but the sole proprietor immediately transfers those funds to a bank account in Ukraine (shown on the statement as an account-to-account transfer), an RRO is not required.
- If the client pays for services from a bank account and the funds reach the sole proprietor's PayPal account, an RRO is not required.
Risks. If the sole proprietor was required to fiscalize this income, failure to use an RRO may result in a fine of 100% of the value of the goods sold or services provided in violation of this requirement.
Important! The statute of limitations for tax disputes is 1095 days (Article 105 of the TCU). This means that only services provided and paid for during this period are at risk of being challenged by the STS.
Our firm is ready to provide a separate consultation on taxation abroad tailored to your specific situation, and to represent you in court if a dispute with the tax authorities arises.
If you are looking for answers today, contact us!
We will help you avoid future risks.
Our clients










