Should You Reject a Deal Because of a Counterparty’s Court and Enforcement Proceedings
Cost of services:
Reviews of our Clients
... our work on joint projects assured us of your high level of professionalism
Before signing a contract, businesses often check their counterparties in court registers and may even find court cases. This can lead to a common mistake: either the client becomes alarmed by any litigation and rejects a reliable partner, or, conversely, ignores a series of potentially serious disputes because “everyone gets sued.”
The legal assessment of court proceedings and enforcement proceedings is not simply about counting the number of cases. Its purpose is to determine whether those cases affect the counterparty’s ability to fulfil your specific transaction.
Does Litigation Mean That a Counterparty Is Unreliable?
A business may be involved in court proceedings for various reasons, including tax disputes, employment disputes, debt recovery, corporate conflicts, disputes with landlords, and disputes over the quality of goods or services.
Therefore, the lawyer’s first question is not “How many cases are there?” but rather “What are these cases about, what stage have they reached, what are the amounts involved, what is the counterparty’s role, and is the dispute related to the risks of our transaction?”
You might also like: Selection and verification of a counterparty when concluding a foreign economic contract
Which Cases Require Particular Attention
- Cases involving claims for significant debts against the counterparty;
- Bankruptcy or insolvency proceedings;
- Corporate disputes concerning ownership interests, the director, authority, or shareholders’ resolutions;
- Cases seeking to invalidate contracts, recover property, or cancel registration actions;
- Tax disputes that may affect the legitimacy of business transactions or the counterparty’s solvency;
- A series of similar claims brought by suppliers, customers, landlords, or employees;
- Cases involving interim measures, such as property seizure or injunctions prohibiting certain actions.
Where to Check a Counterparty’s Court Cases and Enforcement Proceedings: Unified State Register of Court Decisions, ASIP, and the Register of Debtors
Information about court cases can be checked using two official sources:
- The “Case Status” service on the “Judiciary of Ukraine” web portal helps users find the case number, parties, subject matter of the dispute, and stage of proceedings.
- The Unified State Register of Court Decisions (USRCD) provides access to rulings, judgments, and resolutions, which can be analyzed to understand the nature of the dispute and its potential consequences.
You can check information about enforcement proceedings in the Automated System of Enforcement Proceedings (ASIP). Whether a company has been included in the publicly accessible list of debtors can be verified in the Unified Register of Debtors, which forms part of this system.
Legal entities should primarily be searched by their EDRPOU code, and the results should be cross-checked across the different sources.
The absence of an entry in one resource does not, by itself, prove that there is no risk: access to certain information may be restricted, and complete information about a specific enforcement proceeding is available to its parties.
What Enforcement Proceedings Reveal
Enforcement proceedings mean that a court decision or another enforcement document has already reached the stage of compulsory enforcement. This is a stronger warning sign than simply having a claim filed against the counterparty.
One small case is not necessarily critical. However, recurring enforcement proceedings, significant amounts, seizures of bank accounts or property, or a combination of enforcement proceedings with court disputes and tax risks may indicate that the counterparty will be unable to fulfil new obligations.
You might also like: How to Check a Company Before Buying?
5 Warning Signs of Serious Risks in a Counterparty’s Court Cases
- The dispute has already reached the stage of compulsory enforcement. The situation is particularly concerning when several enforcement proceedings have been opened against the counterparty at the same time.
- Claims are accumulating and recurring. A series of similar disputes involving different suppliers, customers, employees, or landlords may indicate not an isolated conflict, but a systemic problem.
- The total amount of claims is substantial. The risk should be assessed in relation to the counterparty’s business scale, the value of the prospective transaction, and the volume of obligations it must fulfil.
- Restrictions have been imposed on funds or property. Seizure of funds, property, or corporate rights, prohibitions on registration actions, or other interim measures may directly hinder the performance of the contract.
- The disputes affect the foundations of the company’s operations. Bankruptcy proceedings, conflicts involving the director or owners, or disputes over key property, permits, or rights to use an asset may jeopardize the company’s ability to fulfil the transaction itself.
The more of these warning signs coincide, the less reason there is to rely on a standard contract alone. At the same time, even one warning sign may be decisive if it is directly related to the subject matter of the transaction or the counterparty’s solvency.
How a Lawyer Assesses the Actual Risk
A lawyer does not assess proceedings in isolation. Instead, they build an overall picture based on:
- the company’s registration status;
- how long it has been operating;
- its business activities;
- its owners, director, and related parties;
- court cases and enforcement proceedings;
- bankruptcy proceedings;
- assets;
- tax-related indicators;
- contractual terms and commercial context.
For a small advance payment, the risk may be acceptable. However, for a high-value supply transaction with deferred payment, the same set of facts may call for a guarantee, collateral, a surety, phased delivery, or withdrawal from the transaction.
Real-Life Cases: When Court Proceedings Represent a Genuine Risk and When They Do Not
Here are several examples from our practice illustrating the difference between a “false alarm” and a genuine threat.
Several Cases Revealed a Genuine Risk
A supplier offered an attractive price but required a 70% advance payment. During the due diligence check, it emerged that several customers had filed similar claims against the supplier over the course of a year because goods had not been delivered and advance payments had not been refunded. Some court decisions had already reached the stage of compulsory enforcement, and in one case, the court had ordered the seizure of the supplier’s property.
The danger lay not in the number of cases itself, but in their direct connection to the prospective transaction: the counterparty had already received advance payments and failed to fulfil similar obligations. The business rejected the substantial advance payment and agreed to work only on the basis of phased payments after each batch had actually been delivered.
Court Cases Did Not Confirm That the Counterparty Was Unreliable
During a distributor due diligence check, more than ten court cases were found. At first glance, this appeared to represent a serious risk. However, in most of the proceedings, the company was the claimant seeking to recover debts from its customers. Several other cases concerned minor employment and lease disputes. No open enforcement proceedings in which the company was the debtor, signs of bankruptcy, or restrictions affecting key assets were identified.
In this case, the company’s litigation activity did not indicate a failure to fulfil its obligations. Rather, it showed that the company was protecting its rights and working with a large number of counterparties. The transaction went ahead, with standard controls for the first delivery and a moderate credit limit in place.
What Decisions Can a Business Make?
- Sign the contract on standard terms if the risk is low.
- Change the payment terms.
- Require security.
- Reduce the credit limit or payment deferral period.
- Place the counterparty under regular monitoring.
- Request explanations, financial documents, or additional evidence.
- Withdraw from the transaction if the risk is unacceptable.
Comprehensive Counterparty Due Diligence: How We Help Assess Risk
We provide comprehensive counterparty due diligence, including:
- checking court and enforcement proceedings not merely to provide a formal report, but as part of the decision-making process regarding the transaction;
- analysing the subject matter and amount of the dispute, the stage of proceedings, and the counterparty’s role;
- assessing whether security is in place, whether disputes are recurring, how they relate to the future contract, and what consequences they may have for the client.
Based on the findings, the client receives an assessment that can be used in negotiations and when drafting the contract.
A counterparty’s court and enforcement proceedings are not simply a matter of being “bad” or “acceptable”. They are a set of indicators that need to be interpreted correctly. Comprehensive legal due diligence helps turn this information into an informed business decision.
Contact our specialists to request a due diligence check and move forward with confidence when entering into a contract.
Our clients












